Spot checks for ferry as SPT say they don’t have to subsidise it

An independent marine engineer has been given ‘carte blanche’ to carry out spot checks on the Kilcreggan to Gourock ferry service, it was revealed tonight.

Calm waters: The Island Princess leaving Kilcreggan pier.
Calm waters: The Island Princess leaving Kilcreggan pier.
But there was a furious response at Cove and Kilcreggan Community Council to reports of apparent threats by Strathclyde Partnership for Transport (SPT) officials.

Robert MacIntyre, Argyll and Bute’s representative on the transport body, said that at a meeting at SPT last week he had told officials that recent problems were ‘not satisfactory in any way’.

But he said an official had countered that if residents were unhappy ‘they could put in for the contract themselves’, adding: “SPT don’t need to subsidise this ferry service, so be careful what you ask for.”

This sparked a furious response from community council secretary Murdo MacDonald, who said: “I regard that as a despicable comment. This ferry service has been completely disastrous since the current company took over, an abysmal service.

“For SPT to say that is disgraceful. That is not an appropriate response.”

Cllr MacIntyre said that problems which had seen the service reduced to 12 passengers per trip last month – rather than the contracted 60 – were not Clydelink’s fault.

“Part of the gearbox had been replaced,” he said.

“The MCA had to check this out before it could sail again, they seemingly took from the Tuesday to the Friday before they could check this.”

Community council chairman Nick Davies said Clydelink might need to develop a better relationship with the MCA, and suggested the priority should be preparing for the contract to be tendered again in 2017.

Cllr MacIntyre said a backup boat was not specified in the contract – Mr Davies said this should be a priority in future.

SPT’s engineer will in future be able to carry out spot checks on the Island Princess with no notice being given, Cllr MacIntyre told the meeting.

Ferry sailings were cancelled twice today because of ‘technical problems’.

Local MSP Jackie Baillie has campaigned for the service to be taken over by Transport Scotland and appeared to encounter intransigence from SPT, but Cllr MacIntyre said the opposite was the case, and SPT didn’t want to continue being responsible for it: “We have asked the Scottish Government to take this over – they don’t want it.”


    • Yes Cllr MacIntyre did say everything quoted in the article, although he was quoting an SPT official in the comments which I guess you’re referring to.

  1. This is disgusting; if we’re getting the job of running our ferry we’ll have this official’s doubtless substantial wages as well please. What unbelievable arrogance this official has.

  2. That the Councillor representing the interests of Argyll and Bute Council which is a partner organising of the quango (SPT) appears to have failed to challenge the unacceptable comment made by an “unnamed” official is extremely worrying when we are surely entitled to assume that ABC is tasked with looking after the interests of its Communities such as ours dependent upon the ferry for work and college and hospital access. All of this ignores the damage to our local tourist visits which add turnover to the hotel/cafe/pub businesses.

    SPT have attempted to avoid any discourse having placed the contract purely for money saving purposes whilst ignoring the fact that ClydeLink failed to honour its commitment to provide a “new” all singing and dancing vessel even after it was alerted to the fact that the so called new boat was in fact the the Solent based summer tours Island Princess!!

    It is surely time for our Community to hold a meeting to let our Councillors know that we expect them to act vigorously in the interests of all commuters and all property owners locally. As a former regular user and former commuter I rarely use the ferry having suffered cancellations requiring a round trip via Glasgow and I am sure I am far from the only one.

  3. Was there any feed back from the meeting Jackie Baillie was having with SPT regarding this service?

  4. Yet again SPT display arrogance stemming from appearing to be completely beyond reproach whatever their actions, it is time the Scottish Government had a serious look at the failures of unaccountability which appear to be built into this ‘public’ body

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. ‘Possible advantages’ in Kilcreggan ferry being run by Transport Scotland, says Minister | The Lochside Press

Comments are closed.